Deer culls not the only answer

  • June 5, 2013
Deer culls not the only answer

Deer culls alone will not promote woodland conservation, according to new research by two Gates Cambridge alumni.

Culling deer will not aid woodland conservation in the absence of other factors, according to a new study by three researchers, including two Gates Cambridge alumni.

The research in the Scottish Highlands, published in Ecology and Evolution, looks at the threat posed by high deer populations to woodlands and grasslands.  The study suggests that deer have a long-term impact on birch regeneration, but that regeneration also requires suitable ground cover for seedlings to grow. It contends that other wildlife such as wild boar could be introduced in the Highlands to further aid tree regeneration by allowing more light to reach seedlings.

The success of deer culling policies in terms of promoting woodland regeneration has been hard to quantify up to now. By developing a spatially explicit simulation model, the authors, Andrew Tanentzap, James Zou and David Coomes, were able to accurately predict the impact of red deer on the conservation of birch woodlands in the Scottish Highlands. Their research is among the first validated tests of the accuracy of such simulation models for predicting the responses of tree regeneration to herbivore numbers. They also looked at the relative importance of other factors on birch regeneration, such as ground cover vegetation and seed availability.

The research suggests managers interested in maximising tree regeneration cannot simply reduce deer densities but must also improve ground cover for seedlings to take root. The research findings enable managers to quantify explicitly how much both these factors need to be altered. More broadly, they emphasise the need for land managers to consider the impact of herbivores like deer rather than their densities and provide them with a tool to do so.

They also argue for the reintroduction of wild boar to the Highlands, saying their trampling and grazing could help seeds to take root by increasing light penetration to the soil surface without entirely inhibiting seed growth. They add: "Both the promotion of extensive livestock production and regulated reintroduction of boar may confer additional socioeconomic benefits for local communities by enhancing important components of the Highland economy, that is, farming and sport shooting."

The research is based on Andrew Tanentzap's 2010 PhD in Plant Sciences for which he was awarded a Gates Cambridge Scholarship. It is written in collaboration with James Zou, another Gates alumnus, as well as David Coomes, who is based at Cambridge. James, who did a CASM in Applied Mathematics, and Andrew, who is now Banting Fellow in the Department of Biology at York University, Canada, met in October 2007 on the Gates Orientation trip to the Lake District and discovered they had joint interests in ecology and applied maths.  Andrew says: "We decided to work together – and after many years – finally found a project on which we could collaborate.  It certainly shows the benefits of talking to your neighbour on the orientation bus!"

For the journal article, click here.

Picture credit: Mehmet Karatay and Wikicommons.

Latest News

Addressing the mental health emergency

Mental health has been rising up the global health priority list over the last few years, but Covid accelerated it. Yet the resources available to those in crisis situations are few. Gates Cambridge Scholar Usama Mirza is addressing one particular gap in his home country of Pakistan, having recently launched Asia’s first mental health ambulance […]

Food security in Africa through a multi-disciplinary lens

Three Gates Cambridge Scholars are collaborating on an innovative project to map and address the disappearance of historically undervalued African indigenous and traditional food crops at a time of climate crisis. The project is the brainchild of Dr Carol Ibe, founder of the JR Biotek Foundation, a charity which trains, upskills and empowers present and […]

Double winner

Jenna Armstrong has done it again. Last year she was part of the winning Cambridge women’s rowing team and her team did it again last weekend. Jenna [2020] started rowing in 2011 as an undergraduate, but took five years off from 2015 to 2020 until she picked it up again when she started at Cambridge. She […]

What does extreme weather mean for us?

Three Gates Cambridge Scholars from China, the US and India are taking part in the third episode of the Gates Cambridge podcast, So, now what? which is out today [26th March] as part of the Cambridge Festival’s Festival of Podcasts. The episode, featuring Victoria Herrmann [2015], Songqiao Yao [2014] and Ramit Debnath [2018] and hosted […]