Humans and robot to debate the future of AI

  • November 19, 2019
Humans and robot to debate the future of AI

Debate veteran Sharmila Parmanand will take part in a live experiment this week when she debates against a robot.

As an experienced debater, I am familiar with my own limitations in terms of my ability to curate my knowledge sources and process huge volumes of data. In this regard, the potential contribution of a thinking machine is huge.

Sharmila Parmanand

A Gates Cambridge Scholar will be one of a number of humans who will debate against a robot at the Cambridge Union in a live experiment this week.

Sharmila Parmanand, an international debate coach, will take part in the debate on 21st November, entitled "Artificial Intelligence will bring more harm than good in the next decade”.

She will debate against Project Debater [pictured], an AI-powered machine developed by IBM. 

Project Debater will deliver the opening speeches for both sides of the debate and the humans in both the for and against teams will develop these arguments further and respond to each other. 

Sharmila will be speaking for the Proposition along with Professor Neil Lawrence, DeepMind Professor of Machine Learning at the University of Cambridge and the co-host of the Talking Machines podcast. 

Speaking against the motion are Professor Sylvie Delacroix, a Law and Ethics at the University of Birmingham and a member of the Public Policy Commission on the use of algorithms in the justice system, and Harish Natarajan, a champion debater and Head of Economic Risk Analysis at global tracking company AKE International in London.

At the heart of the experiment is the speech-by-crowd approach that will be taken by Project Debater. The machine will be collecting arguments from the audience, validating their quality, clustering them and presenting them in an organised and coherent fashion. 

Sharmila says: "Considering the subjective nature of debating (unlike math equations or say, chess, which has clearer score functions), it is exciting to see how well the machine will synthesise arguments and engage with and deploy elements of persuasion such as humour and figures of speech. As an experienced debater, I am familiar with my own limitations in terms of my ability to curate my knowledge sources and process huge volumes of data. In this regard, the potential contribution of a thinking machine is huge. 

"The event aims to showcase what a discussion can look like when we combine professionals in a field, experts in critical thinking and technology powered by a mass audience." 

Sharmila [2016], who is doing a PhD in Multidisciplinary Gender Studies, says her team is likely to argue that the development of AI happens in a social and political context that makes regulation and public scrutiny difficult and where the most at-risk populations have the least access to political capital to advocate for themselves. She says this can lead to huge harms such as the entrenchment of problematic algorithms in criminal sentencing and predictive policing, mass-scale privacy violations and surveillance to suppress political dissent. She states: "By acknowledging these risks, we can contribute to the conversations on AI governance and the attempts to ensure the development of safe and beneficial AI."

*For more information about the event, click here.

 

Sharmila Parmanand

Sharmila Parmanand

  • Alumni
  • Philippines
  • 2016 PhD Multi-disciplin Gender Studies
  • Homerton College

My research projects interrogate how development and state interventions targeted at women in the global south reflect and shape their lived realities, with a focus on gender and international development, the politics of knowledge production, and feminist entanglements with the state on issues of human rights and women’s precarious labour.

Previous Education

University of Melbourne
Ateneo de Manila University

Latest News

Gates Cambridge at the Cambridge Festival

Gates Cambridge Scholars will be speaking at the Cambridge Festival next month on a range of topics, from climate change social entrepreneurs to local currencies and AI. The Cambridge Festival  runs from 13th to 28th March and is teeming with hundreds of events, most of them free, which celebrate the rich research being done at the […]

First cohort of 2024 Gates Cambridge Scholars announced

Twenty-six of the most academically outstanding and socially committed US citizens have been selected to be part of the 2024 class of Gates Cambridge Scholars at the University of Cambridge. The US Scholars-elect, who will take up their awards this October, are from a wide range of backgrounds. They come from 20 universities across the […]

What is education for?

Best-selling author Tara Westover [2009], researcher Aliya Khalid [2015] and Thabo Msibi [2009], Deputy Vice Chancellor for Teaching and Learning at the University of KwaZulu-Natal are the guests in the second edition of the Gates Cambridge podcast – out today. So, now what? sees the three Gates Cambridge Scholars tackling the issue of what education […]

Why technology needs feminism

What is good technology? Is ‘good’ technology even possible? And how can feminism contribute towards it? Those questions and more are at the heart of a new book co-edited by Gates Cambridge Scholar Dr Kerry McInerney and based on the popular podcast series she co-hosts. The Good Robot: Why technology needs feminism gathers together the thoughts of leading […]